Skip to main content

ACL Tears

What is the ACL?

The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is one of the main ligaments in the center of the knee. It runs from the front of the tibia (shinbone) to the back of the femur (thighbone). It assists in proper movement of the knee joint and prevents the tibia from slipping forward on the femur. Abnormal translation can create an unstable knee that “gives way” during activity.

How do you tear your ACL?

The ACL is most commonly injured during a twisting or pivoting episode of the knee when the foot is planted on the ground. This can occur during such sports as football, soccer, basketball, or skiing. It can also be injured during a direct blow to the knee, or with hyperflexion or hyperextension of the knee.

What are torn ACL symptoms?

Usually, an ACL tear results in sudden pain and sensation of the knee giving out. Many patients report having felt or heard a “pop” when they injure their knee. In addition, the knee commonly swells within the first 1 to 3 hours after the injury. If the ACL tear is more chronic in nature, the injury most commonly leads to shifting or the knee giving out with activity. An examination in our office can usually determine how severe your ACL tear is by testing the ability of the ligament to prevent the tibia from moving forward on the femur. Request an appointment today.

Do I need an X-ray, MRI, or any other test?

A set of X-rays is typically ordered to evaluate the bones around the knee. The X-rays are primarily used to evaluate for fractures or arthritis around the knee. The MRI may be ordered to look for damage to the ACL and rule out any other injuries to the knee such as a meniscus tear or bone bruise. Other ligament or cartilage injuries can occur in combination with injuries to the ACL, which can be seen on the MRI. A KT-1000 Knee Ligament Arthometer is another test commonly performed in the office to evaluate how unstable the knee may be.

Is there other damage to the knee when the ACL is torn?

Other ligaments in the knee can be injured at the same time as the ACL. The most common ligament to also be injured is the medial collateral ligament or MCL. This ligament is on the inside of the knee and prevents the legs from moving inward.

In many cases, a meniscus tear can occur at the time of an ACL injury. The medial and lateral meniscus are the cartilage rings that sit on the inside and outside of the knee. Some meniscus tears can be repaired (fixed), others need to be trimmed back so that the torn edges are smooth (partial meniscectomy). Whether or not the meniscus can be fixed or trimmed depends on the location, size, and age of the tear. All attempts are made to try and repair a meniscus that will heal.

In some cases, there is also injury to the articular cartilage (the cartilage surface of the knee). The MRI will usually detect this injury, but sometimes it is not seen. This injury will also be addressed at the time of surgery, if necessary.

What are the ACL treatment options?

The ACL cannot heal on its own, but not all ACL tears need to be fixed with surgery. Whether or not the ACL needs to be treated depends on your desired activity level. The ACL is most important with cutting and twisting sports, such as tennis, basketball, soccer, skiing, etc. People with strenuous jobs involving heavy lifting and climbing also typically use their ACL heavily. People who are unwilling or unable to modify their activities and desire an unrestricted lifestyle are encouraged to consider ACL surgery.

People who lead a more sedentary lifestyle may be able to get by with exercise and a brace to stabilize the knee. However, some people may experience instability with simple activities such as going down stairs or stepping off a curb. In these cases, surgery is recommended to restore normal everyday activities and prevent further damage to the knee.

What is ACL surgery?

Since the ACL does not heal, the ligament needs to be replaced (reconstructed). The ACL is reconstructed with arthroscopic surgery. The arthroscope is a fiber-optic instrument (narrower than a pen) that is put into the knee joint through small incisions. A camera is attached to the arthroscope, and the image is viewed on a TV monitor. The arthroscope allows the surgeon to fully evaluate the entire knee joint, including the kneecap (patella), the cartilage surfaces, the meniscus, the ligaments (ACL & PCL), and the joint lining. Small instruments ranging from 3-5 millimeters in size are inserted through the incisions so that the surgeon can feel the joint structures for any damage, diagnose the injury, and then repair, reconstruct, or remove the damaged tissue.

In ACL reconstruction, a replacement graft (ligament) is positioned in the joint at the site of the former ACL and then fixed to the thigh and lower leg using a metal button and small plate with a post. Although the ACL reconstruction is performed primarily with arthroscopy, a small open incision is needed to place the ligament in the knee. Depending on the type of ligament graft used, an incision may be needed to obtain the graft from your knee.

What kind of graft is used for the new ligament?

Choices for the type of replacement graft include autografts (using your own tissue) or allografts (donor tissue from a cadaver). Autograft tissue used for ACL reconstruction can either be from your patellar tendon (central 1/3 patellar tendon) or the hamstring tendons. The central 1/3 patellar tendon is taken with a small piece of bone from the patella and the tibia. It requires an incision on the front of the knee. It is the graft that has been used the longest and is the most common graft performed. It has excellent long-term results and is used for most professional athletes. The disadvantage of a patellar tendon graft is that it can cause more pain for the first several weeks after surgery and can lead to pain in the front of the knee in a small number of patients.

A hamstring autograft is taken from a small incision towards the inside of the knee. The graft also has excellent results but has not been used as long as the patellar tendon grafts. Its disadvantage is it can lead to some weakness in the hamstring muscles. It is commonly used in patients who may be predisposed to pain in the front of the knee.

Allograft tissue is tissue donated from a cadaver. Allograft is also a strong graft with excellent results for ACL reconstruction. Because the tissue is not taken from your body, the surgical time and operative pain are less. This generally allows for an easier rehabilitation. The tissue is rigorously screened for infections, including HIV and Hepatitis. The disadvantage to the allograft tissue is that it has a slightly lowered success rate compared to the autograft tissue.

What are possible ACL surgery complications?

While complications are not common, all surgery has associated risks. Possible complications include stiffness of the knee after surgery or continued pain. The use of arthroscopic techniques attempts to limit these complications. In addition, there is a risk of continued instability or rupture of the ACL graft. Other complications include infection, bleeding, nerve damage, blood clots, or problems with the anesthesia.

When should my ACL surgery be performed?

ACL surgery is not an emergency. In fact, it is extremely important that the surgeon delay your surgery until some of the inflammation in your knee reduces. The goal of waiting is to allow you to regain full motion back in your knee prior to surgery. In general, this takes 2 to 3 weeks for most patients, but it can vary. The reason to wait until full motion is achieved is that loss of motion before surgery can make it more likely for the knee to become stiff after surgery.

What kind of anesthesia is used?

ACL reconstruction is usually performed with general anesthesia, where you go to sleep. If you go home the same day you will be given a femoral nerve block to control postoperative pain.

What do I need to do to prepare for ACL surgery?

Our staff will help to set up the surgery through your insurance company and will instruct you on any paperwork that may be necessary. If you are over the age of 50 or have significant health conditions, you may need an EKG and chest X-ray. You may also need to see your internist or family doctor to obtain a Letter of Medical Clearance. The day before the surgery, a member of the hospital or surgery center staff will contact you about what time to arrive for surgery. Do not eat or drink anything after midnight before your surgery.

How long will I be in the hospital?

Most patients are able to go home the same day.

What happens on the day of ACL surgery?

When you arrive at the surgery center, you will be admitted and taken to a preoperative holding area where you are prepared for surgery. You will be asked several times which extremity the surgeon will be operating on. Please note that you are asked this question many times on purpose. Anesthesia will be administered and the surgery is then performed.

After the operation, you will be taken to the recovery room to be monitored. Once the effects of the anesthesia have worn off and your pain is under good control, you will be given your postoperative instructions, prescription for pain medication, and released.

Please be aware that the process of checking in, preparing for surgery, undergoing the operation, and recovering from anesthesia takes the majority of the day. It is recommended that your driver bring some reading material for the duration.

How should I care for my knee after surgery?

Prior to your discharge, you will be given specific instructions on how to care for your knee. In general, you can expect the following:

You will be given a prescription for pain medication.

You may shower, but you should keep the dressing dry. After your dressing is removed, you may get your knee wet. You cannot take a bath until the wounds are completely sealed, which is usually 2-3 weeks after surgery.

You will be instructed how to use crutches before the surgery. You should bring a set of crutches with you to the surgery. Crutches are commonly used for the first 1 to 2 weeks post-op. The therapist will work with you to get you off your crutches when it is safe.

You will receive a brace for your knee that you will wear for the first two weeks after surgery. The brace is locked in full extension (knee straight) because that is the hardest motion to get back after surgery. When you are not walking you may take the brace off intermittently to work on your exercises.

Resume your regular diet as soon as tolerated. It is best to start with clear liquids before advancing to solid food.

You may be given a continuous cold therapy unit for your knee. It is a pad that wraps around your knee and provides cold to your knee. If not, you should apply ice over the dressing for 30 minutes every 1-2 hours for several days. Do not use heat the first week after surgery.

Suture removal:
Your stitches will be removed at your 2-week office visit.

You will be instructed on exercises you can begin immediately after the surgery.

Return to work or school:
Your physician will talk with you regarding returning to work or school. Return depends on pain levels and comfort with ambulation with crutches.

What will ACL recovery involve?

The rehabilitation is based on several goals:

  1. Allowing the tissue to heal
  2. Regaining your range of motion
  3. Regaining strength
  4. Returning to sports or work activity

Initially, the most important part of the rehabilitation program initially is making sure the knee gets complete extension (totally straight). Following this, the emphasis is to get your knee bending properly. The rehab program is just as important as the surgery in achieving a good result. Typically, you will be in therapy 2 times per week for 3-4 months.

When can I return to sports or full duty at work?

In general, you will be allowed to return to sports in 4-6 months after surgery. You must have good motion, strength, and control of your knee. How quickly you return to sports depends on several factors, including:

  1. Your own rate of healing
  2. The damage found at surgery
  3. If you have any complications
  4. How well you follow the postoperative instructions
  5. How hard you work in rehabilitation

In most cases, it will take 6 months to return to cutting and pivoting sports. When you are able to return to full duty at work depends on your job requirements. The physician will help to spell this out more clearly at your office visits.

Will I need a brace after ACL surgery for sports?

With a successful surgery and dedicated rehabilitation, you do not need a brace after ACL reconstruction. Occasionally, a patient will request to use a brace of the first year and that is okay.

What is the ACL surgery success rate?

Overall, ACL reconstruction is a highly successful operation. The advances in surgical techniques and rehabilitation have led to a 95% success rate for achieving a stable knee following surgery.

ACL Treatment St. Louis

Mark Miller, MD is committed to you — the patient. It is understandable to be anxious about your injury and the need for ACL repair. As one of the leading knee specialists and orthopedic surgeons in the St. Louis area, Dr. Mark Miller has expertly managed ACL tear treatment for countless patients. You can trust us to answer all questions and provide you with the highest-quality care.

Schedule an appointment to begin managing your ACL tear symptoms with a personalized treatment plan!

Accreditations & Associations